Chosen Forums

BlckTrs_3 · Guest

What is your fav Harry Potter Book, and why?? Here we can discuss the Harry Potter books and tell ppl y u liked them and what one was your fav!

I like them all, really I can't pick!! I like OotP... no HBP... No GoF! ROAR see i can't pick, they are all really good it's not fair... I would have to say the HBP tho... I mean it was sad and all, but, like... I can't explain... I just really liked it... I liked them all but I reallly liked the HBP... I have tonz of Q's b/c of it and I like a book to keep me asking Q's... so I guess that is y... but that could go the same for the OotP... I dunno.. I can't pick!! lol...

what's yours??

Guest · Posted: Thu Sep 14, 2006 1:05 am Post subject:

I voted for The Order of the Pheonix. To me, it's the most dark. And it also had a wicked battle at the end. It was sad (The ending). But, the whole book was cool. It was the longest and that's good because I didn't want to finish it! At first, my favourite was The Goblet of Fire, but when I read this one I thought it was the best! The Half-Blood Prince was okay. I didn't like the ending. And there wasn't any Voldemort in it! Sad

BlckTrs_3 · Guest

Yea having no Voldemort in the books are ppls main reasons for not likeing them.. But I find that a stupid excuse ((no offence))... Just b/c it's a Harry Potter book doesn't mean that it HAS to have him in it...

I agree that the 5th book was darker, and I liked that about it... and that is another reason y I couldn't decide about what one I liked the most.... lol

Aaron_Nichols · Admin Joined: 12 Sep 2006 Posts: 375 Location: HERE

It is a Harry Potter book and that DOES mean that it has to have Voldemort in it. He is the second main charecter in the book and not having him or having little of him just makes it boring. I like HBP because as stated before it left me questions and all that. I also liked how it killed Dumbledore, I mean that is sad and all but it is a big part in the book. Plus I didnt see that coming.

BlckTrs_3 · Guest

well I kno that... but I mean, Harry Potter isn't JUST about Voldemort.. I kno he is an important part of it and everything... but if it had him in it the whole time, it would all just be fighting and junk... and we need to know other things then just fighting... if that made n e sense please tell me... b/c it didn't to me... lol...

Aaron_Nichols · Admin Joined: 12 Sep 2006 Posts: 375 Location: HERE

The thing did make sense to me. I mean yea we dont need fighting but a book without Voldie is just not a book......I like the action or information but it should have Voldie.

Guest · Posted: Sat Sep 16, 2006 9:42 am Post subject:

I can't believe Dumbledore got killed in the last book by Snape. It was sad, because Dumbledore could believe it and didn't want to accept it.

Aaron_Nichols · Admin Joined: 12 Sep 2006 Posts: 375 Location: HERE

Well some, me, believe that DD asked Snape to kill him. It is sad that DD did die but it was needed.

BlckTrs_3 · Guest

well... I think that is possable... ya kno?? but I dunno... it's still confusing...

Aaron_Nichols · Admin Joined: 12 Sep 2006 Posts: 375 Location: HERE

We will not truly know until the release of the seventh book. I can not wait for this book to come out. It should be really good, even though it will be shorter than OotP.